Which is Better Investment: Manufactured Home or Site-built Home

manuf homes liberty_homes__mh__their_creditResponding to a question in coumbusdispatch from a couple regarding the long term investment value of a manufactured home, Ilyce Glink and lawyer Samuel Tamkin, who co-author a column on real estate, reply the most important concern is that the home complies with all federal HUD Code standards, post 1976, preferably a newer one, and the home is permanently installed on a foundation.

Noting a site-built home is titled with the land and recorded as a warranty deed, whereas a manufactured home (MH) is titled more like a car or a boat, the team says the market for MH and lender availability is much more limited than for a traditional home. It is important to compare the costs of owning the MH and renting the land, versus the costs of owning a stick-built home over a five year period.

While it is true that manufactured homes are titled, the authors in the columbusdispatch fail to mention that manufactured homes can be titled and financed the same as real property. While the example given was in an MHC, 2 out of 3 MHs are placed on privately owned land, outside of an MH land lease community.

Further, the respondents failed to make clear that there are numerous potential advantages to a land-lease vs. buying property. An MH on land lease may have little or no real estate or personal property taxes. One saves the initial cost of the land. Trulia recently showed a report that indicated the average stay in a home is about 7 years. Notably in such a scenario, the site built home buyer is going to be paying more than their MH counterpart in a land lease.

The article concludes correctly by saying a home shopper should compare all the facts, but it could have been improved with added insights, such as those noted above. ##

(Photo credit: Liberty Homes-manufactured home)

matthew-silver-daily-business-news-mhpronews-com  Article submitted by Matthew J. Silver to Daily Business News-MHProNews.

mas kovach mhpronews shopping with soheyla .jp

Get our ‘read-hot’ industry-leading 

get our ‘read-hot’ industry-leading emailed headline news updates

Scroll to Top